---

REFEREE REPORT FORM

SAMPLE NOT TO BE USED BY OUR REFEREES, THEY FOLLOW THE LINK PROVIDED IN OUR EMAIL.

Referee #
Manuscript # AR...
General comments 1) Does this article provide a comprehensive study or a report?
	nothing selected yes no
2) The introduction is understandable for a general audience?
	nothing selected yes no
3) How important do you consider the results reported?
	nothing selected very important important less important unimportant
4) Do the data obtained by experiment or calculation verify the hypotheses and conclusions?
	nothing selected Yes No *)
5) Is the length of the manuscript appropriate to its contents?
	nothing selected Yes No, the manuscript is too long *) No, the manuscript is too short *)
Specific comments on Technical Content 6) Materials, methods, techniques, and statistical analysis?
	nothing selected Adequate Inadequate *)
7) Presentation and clarity of results?
	nothing selected Adequate Inadequate *)
8) Discussion and conclusions?
	nothing selected Adequate Inadequate *)
9) Logic and coherence?
	nothing selected Adequate Inadequate *)
Specific comments on Presentation and Style 10) Clarity and quality of writing?
	nothing selected Good Minor revision Extensive revision
11) Is the abstract a good summary of the paper?
	nothing selected Yes No
12) Number of tables
	nothing selected Too few Adequate number Too many
13) Tables are well presented?
	nothing selected Yes No
14) Number of figures
	nothing selected Too few Adequate number Too many
15) Figures are well presented?
	nothing selected Yes No
16) Number of references
	nothing selected Too few Adequate number Too many
17) Do you recommend acceptance of the article?
	nothing selected Yes, without alterations Yes, after minor alterations *) Yes, but only after major alterations *) No *)
*) Please give comments here:
DO NEVER USE THIS SITE TO PREPARE A REPORT

---

© Applied Rheology 2024